May 11, 2010
Phony 3-D Movies Hitting Hollywood
Hollywood industry analysts have warned that the 3-D craze could be in jeopardy if studios sacrifice quality in order to cash in on movie-making's most important technology milestone since color films.
While James Cameron's science-fiction "Avatar" provided ground-breaking confirmation of what 3-D technology is capable of, the Greek mythology remake "Clash of the Titans" was an illustration of what can go wrong.
"Avatar" was shot using state-of-the-art 3-D cameras, while "Titans" was shot in 2-D and hastily converted into 3-D during post production. Cameron said he waited for technology to "catch up" with his imagination.
"A few more 3-D spectacles like 'Clash of the Titans' and audiences will be clamoring for 2-D," was the withering assessment of the Wall Street Journal.
Head of Dreamworks Animation Jeffrey Katzenberg warned in a recent interview with Variety that the movie industry was at a "genuine crossroads."
Katzenberg said that movie-goers who have been happy to pay more at the box-office for quality 3-D will quickly wise up if they feel they are being served up an inferior product.
"We've seen the highest end of 3-D (in 'Avatar') and you have now witnessed the lowest end of it (in 'Titans')," Katzenberg told AFP.
"You cannot do anything that is of a lower grade and a lower quality than what has just been done on 'Clash of the Titans'. It literally is 'OK, congratulations! You just snookered the movie audience."
"We may get away with it a few times but in the long run, (moviegoers) will wake up. And the day they wake up is the day they walk away from us and we blew it," Katzenberg added.
Managing editor of thewrap.com website Lew Harris said the experience of "Clash of the Titans" could have implications for persistent speculation that classic films like "Star Wars" and "Titanic" may be re-released in 3-D.
"I think it depends on how they do it," Harris told AFP. "By the time these films come out a lot of the 3-D novelty is going to be over.
"And a lot of people are going to be tired of paying for 3-D, particularly if there are lots of films where the 3-D hasn't been good.
"Will people go and see 'Titanic' in 3-D? I think they might, just out of curiosity. It's a 'big' movie. You've got the huge spectacle of a ship sinking, people plunging into the water. It would be an interesting 3-D experience."
However, Harris also believes Hollywood will need to be selective in determining which films from the past can be repackaged in 3-D.
"They're going to have to be careful that people don't get turned off," he told AFP. "In a lot of cases it's questionable how much the 3-D really adds to the experience. Disney's talking about 'Beauty and the Beast' in 3-D.
"But they're going to have to prove that 3-D adds enough of a differentiation. I saw 'Up' in 3-D and I don't think there was anything I would have lost by having seen it in 2-D."
David Wertheimer, the chief of executive of the University of Southern California's Entertainment Technology Center and the former president of Paramount Digital Entertainment, said artistic obstacles sometimes prevented films from being successfully converted to 3-D.
"Most people don't realize that there is an 'art' to making great 3-D," Wertheimer said in comments emailed to AFP. "It's not just about the technology and creating a second eye view.
"Most 3-D films being distributed today have 3-D in mind from conception. The shots in those films are being staged and framed differently.
"They're being edited differently to maximize the 'effect' that the depth has on the story and the experience.
"The problem with converting live action movies from 2-D to 3-D is that some of the creative choices that the director and DP (director of photography) originally made are different from how you would want them in 3-D.
"It is sometimes impossible to make comfortable 3-D out of 2-D shots that are framed in a certain fashion. So, it's an entirely new creative process in converting that film to 3-D."
Wertheimer believes classic films like "Star Wars" and "Titanic" could be successfully converted, provided the makers of the original films are closely involved in the process.
"In the hands of the original creators, the likelihood of success is great (assuming enough time and budget to do it right)," he wrote.