May 25, 2006
Harsher Abu Ghraib methods condoned: witness
By Stuart Grudgings
FORT MEADE, Maryland (Reuters) - Senior U.S. officials
silently condoned harsher methods at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison
and one general urged guards to use dogs to the "maximum extent
possible" to control detainees, witnesses said on Thursday.
of Army dog handler Sgt. Santos Cardona, 32, who is accused of
taking part in abuse of detainees at Abu Ghraib that the U.S.
government blames on rogue low-ranking soldiers.
Defense attorneys are trying to show that Cardona, who
faces 16 years in prison if convicted on all charges, and other
soldiers were acting on orders from their superiors.
Prosecutors say he and an already convicted colleague were
"corrupt cops" who used dogs to terrify detainees into
urinating and defecating on themselves.
Steven Pescatore, a former Air Force officer who worked as
a civilian interrogator at Abu Ghraib, said in written
testimony that silence from superiors on the treatment of
prisoners was widely seen as meaning consent.
"We still had to submit a memo requesting the harsher
techniques, but we could go under the assumption that a
technique was approved unless we heard back otherwise," he
"There was a lot of pressure and stress among the
interrogators; we were constantly being told that we needed to
get more information from the detainees."
Despite evidence of pressure from above to extract more
information from prisoners, there are few signs that senior
Army leaders or administration officials will be charged with
condoning the abuse.
The U.S. government, which often justifies its foreign
policy on the grounds of improving human rights, was severely
embarrassed when photographs showing prisoners being abused and
sexually humiliated were leaked in 2004.
Another witness said that the former commander of the U.S.
military prison at Guantanamo Bay urged the use of dogs to
control prisoners, but not in interrogations.
U.S. Army Maj. Gen. Geoffrey Miller was sent to Iraq from
the Cuba base to try to improve information gathering as the
insurgency intensified after the March 2003 invasion.
Ten low-ranking soldiers have so far been convicted of
abusing prisoners, including the use of snarling, unmuzzled
dogs in late 2003 and early 2004 after Miller arrived.
"All I can recall is him encouraging using them (dogs) to
the maximum extent possible," retired Lt. Col. Jerry
Phillabaum, who was in command of Abu Ghraib before September
2003, told the court in a military base in Maryland.
"I don't recall him saying anything about interrogations."
Miller, the highest-ranking officer to testify in the
scandal, on Wednesday denied he suggested using military dogs
in interrogations of Iraqi prisoners, undercutting Cardona's
Prosecutors say there were clear rules on the treatment of
prisoners that were flouted by Cardona and another dog handler,
Sgt. Michael Smith, who was convicted in March and sentenced to
179 days in prison.