Quantcast

Ultrasound-Guided Surgery Is Best Way To Remove Breast Tumors

March 24, 2012

Technique should become the new standard of care

The use of ultrasound-guided surgery to remove tumors from women who have palpable breast cancer is much more successful than standard surgery in excising all the cancerous tissue while sparing as much healthy tissue as possible, according to the results of a randomized controlled trial.

As a consequence, researchers told the eighth European Breast Cancer Conference (EBCC-8) today (Friday) they expect their findings will change surgical practice and ultrasound-guided surgery (USS) should become the norm for excising palpable tumors i.e. those that can be felt and, at present, are excised “blindly”, without visual aid from tools to help locate the precise position of the tumor during surgery.

When surgeons opt for breast conserving surgery and remove only the tumor rather than the whole breast, they need to include a margin of cancer-free tissue around the tumor during the surgery. This is so that they can be fairly sure that they have removed all the cancerous tissue in order to reduce the chance of local recurrence to a minimum when combined with standard radiotherapy. The margin of “healthy” tissue is analyzed to check that it is free of cancer cells, and if it is not, then further surgery, or an additional radiotherapy boost may be required.

Dr Nicole Krekel, a PhD student in the department of surgical oncology and resident doctor in plastic and reconstructive surgery at VU University Medical Center in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, told the meeting: “Breast-conserving surgery for palpable breast cancer is generally performed with guidance from surgeon’s palpation only, without help from intra-operative tumor localization techniques. The standard method of surgery for non-palpable breast cancer involves a wire to identify the area of cancerous tissue that the surgeon needs to remove — a technique known as wire localization. Unfortunately, both methods of excision are associated with a high rate of margins that contain cancer cells, as well as the excision of excessively large volumes of tissue. Despite studies showing the benefits of USS over wire localization for non-palpable breast cancer, remarkably USS has not been widely integrated into daily surgical practice. In contrast to non-palpable tumors, there has been little research into the use of USS for palpable breast cancer.”

Dr Krekel and her colleagues randomized 124 patients with palpable early stage breast cancer to either USS or standard palpation-guided surgery (PGS). They found that among the 61 women in the USS group only 3.3% of the margins contained cancerous cells compared with 16.4% among the 63 women in the PGS group. As a result, USS resulted in a significant reduction in re-excisions, mastectomies and extra radiotherapy. The amount of healthy tissue removed in the USS group was smaller than in the PGS group (40 cubic centimeters versus 58 cc respectively).

By measuring the volume of the tissue excised during surgery and the actual tumor diameters, the researchers calculated the amount of excess healthy tissue that had been removed, which gave them the “calculated resection ratio” (CRR). A CRR of 1.0 would indicate the ideal amount of tissue had been removed, while a CRR of 2.0 would indicate that double the amount necessary had been removed. They found that the CRR in the USS group was 1.0 (ideal), while in the PGS group it was 1.9.

“Our results show that USS can prevent the unacceptably high rate of margins containing cancer cells in palpable breast cancer excision, thus avoiding subsequent surgery or radiotherapy. In addition, USS largely reduces the amount of unnecessary healthy breast tissue resection, thereby contributing to the improvement of cosmetic results,” said Dr Krekel.

“The trial was only completed in February this year and the results are striking. By using USS, 96.7% of all tumors were excised with adequate, tumor-free margins, compared with only 83.4% in the PGS group, yet the volume of tissue excised was significantly smaller in the USS group.

“The clinical implications of our study are tremendous and we believe they should be included in international guidelines. Given the overwhelming advantages of ultrasound-guided surgery, ‘blind’, palpation-guided excisions should be completely replaced, with ultrasound-guided surgery becoming the standard of care for both palpable and non-palpable breast cancer surgery. The surgeon performing adequate ultrasound will clearly provide better surgical practice. It is therefore highly recommended for surgeons to learn the skills needed to perform USS.”

Dr Krekel said the reason why USS was superior to PGS was because it enabled surgeons to see all round the tumor while they were performing the operation. “Intra-operative US enables the surgeon to optimally position the incision on the breast, and to operate under direct vision. This provides the surgeon with more precision in localizing tumors and determining the size of the lesions than palpation alone, and allows intra-operative orientation, and assessment of surgical margins. It allows complete tumor removal, while continuously monitoring the maintenance of adequate, small resection margins without unnecessarily sacrificing healthy breast tissue. After excision, the completeness of tumor excision can be checked once again with US. The technique is non-invasive, simple, safe and effective, and can be easily learned, ” she explained.

Professor David Cameron, from the University of Edinburgh (Edinburgh, UK), and chair of EBCC-8 said: “This study offers the promise of more successful breast conserving surgery for women with early breast cancer. If the pathologist reports that there is still cancer present at the margin of an excision, usually more surgery is needed: importantly, this study offers a way to reduce the chance of this. However, it is a report from only one hospital, and these findings need confirmation from other teams of surgeons before they should become standard practice.”

On the Net:




comments powered by Disqus