Common Colon Cancer Test Misses Growths in Women
Posted on: Wednesday, 18 May 2005, 18:00 CDT
BOSTON -- A widely used screening tool for colon cancer, sigmoidoscopy, misses precancerous growths in almost two-thirds of women - a disturbing failure rate twice as high as the one seen in men, a government-backed study found.
"All our data until now has been based on men. What this data shows is it's a lot worse in women," said Dr. Philip Schoenfeld of the University of Michigan and U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.
The researchers said colonoscopy - a more reliable but more expensive test than sigmoidoscopy - should now be considered the preferred method for most women.
Even before the study, patients were increasingly choosing colonoscopies, in part because of serious questions about the reliability of sigmoidoscopies. The latest research is likely to accelerate the trend.
Both colonoscopy and sigmoidoscopy involve the use of a long, flexible tube to inspect the twisting colon for precancerous growths, or polyps. But a colonoscope is longer and is used to examine the entire 6-foot length of the colon, while a sigmoidoscope inspects only the lower 2 feet or so.
The new study, led by Schoenfeld, involved 1,463 women, ages 50 to 79, at four military hospitals. It was published Thursday in The New England Journal of Medicine and funded by the National Cancer Institute.
The researchers first used colonoscopes to find all polyps. They then calculated how many worrisome ones would have been missed by sigmoidoscopy alone.
Sigmoidoscopes were already in question because they find precancerous tumors in only 66 percent of average-risk men who have them. In this new study, sigmoidoscopes did even worse in average-risk women, detecting precancerous tumors in just 35 percent of the patients who had them.
Medical guidelines recommend either regular sigmoidoscopies or colonoscopies after age 50. The number of colonoscopies has already been rising in recent years, especially among high-risk patients. A federal survey put the number of colonoscopies at 14 million in 2002, compared to 3 million sigmoidoscopies.
Sigmoidoscopies are still performed for several reasons. A sigmoidoscopy is quicker, it is more convenient because it does not require the use of a sedative, and it costs far less than of a colonoscopy - perhaps $150 instead of $400 or more.
Also, many doctors had believed that the failure rate for sigmoidoscopies would be similar for both sexes.
A recent study by the Veterans Affairs Department found that demand for colonoscopies already outstrips availability. The researchers estimated that more than 30,000 additional doctors would be needed to screen people once every 10 years.
About 56,000 Americans are expected to die of colorectal cancer this year.
Source: Associated Press/AP Online
Related Articles
- Research Finds Women Slightly More Likely To Die Than Men In The 30 Days Following A Heart Attack
- New Study Reveals Swimming Can Cut Men's Risk of Dying in Half
- Obese Women More Impulsive Study Finds
- Hewitt Research Shows Women Much Less Prepared to Retire Than Men
- Gamma Secretase Modulators Show Promise in Alzheimer's Disease Animal Model Efficacy Studies, According to Research Conducted By TorreyPines Therapeutics
- BioSante Pharmaceuticals Comments on New Data From Women's Health Initiative Study Showing No Increased Risk of Breast Cancer With Estrogen-Alone Therapy
- New Data From the Women's Health Initiative Study Show No Increased Risk of Breast Cancer With Conjugated Estrogens Alone
- New Data From Women's Health Initiative Study Show No Increased Risk of Coronary Heart Disease With Conjugated Estrogens Alone In Any Age Group Studied
- Tai Chi Helps Women Recover From Breast Cancer Surgery: Researcher
- The Norwegian Women and Cancer Study (NOWAC): Different Statistical Methods to Assess the Reproducibility of a Food Frequency Questionnaire
 |
 |
User Comments (0)
RSS Feeds