May 8, 2006
Italy president vote ends in stalemate
By Robin Pomeroy
ROME (Reuters) - Italy's lawmakers failed to elect a new
president on Monday as a split between Romano Prodi's left and
Silvio Berlusconi's right produced a stalemate in the first
round of voting for the next head of state.
No candidate secured the two-thirds majority required to
elect the president in the first three rounds of voting.
"We need to proceed to a second round of voting," lower
house speaker Fausto Bertinotti said.
The inconclusive vote means that Italy's 1,010 "grand
electors" will convene again on Tuesday to try to elect a
president but voting could go on until Wednesday and beyond if
Italy's divided political class fails to agree on a name.
Although Italy's president has a largely ceremonial role,
finding a replacement for Carlo Azeglio Ciampi, whose
seven-year term expires this month, comes at a crucial moment
as Prodi can not take office until the new leader gives him a
Prodi tried but failed to persuade the center right --
which he narrowly beat in April's election -- to vote for his
candidate, 80-year-old life senator Giorgio Napolitano, of the
Democrats of the Left (DS), the biggest party in his bloc.
But shortly before the lawmakers went into booths in
parliament to cast their secret ballots, Berlusconi said his
center-right bloc would vote for his close aide Gianni Letta.
Letta got the most votes in the election with 369, but 438
ballots were left blank. The two-thirds majority is 674 votes.
Earlier in the day, as it became clear that Napolitano
would not secure a two-thirds majority, Prodi told center-left
lawmakers to post blank ballots rather than write the
candidate's name which would have tainted him with defeat.
Several lawmakers made mischievous or protest votes,
writing names of notable prisoners, a famous singer and even
Prodi said the center left had decided on the blank ballot
tactic while it waited for more signals from the center right
on the possibility of agreeing on a candidate in the second or
third rounds which will take place on Tuesday.
But when asked if the election would succeed on Tuesday,
Berlusconi told reporters: "I don't think that's possible."
By the fourth round, which would happen on Wednesday if the
stalemate continues, a simple majority is sufficient, meaning
Prodi may be able to push his candidate through against the
But that would only increase the bitterness between the two
camps and could make it harder for Prodi to carry through his
policy program once in government.
Whether Napolitano, a former interior minister and
parliamentary speaker, remains the center left's candidate is
Members of DS, the biggest party in Prodi's coalition,
initially wanted its chairman, the 57-year-old former prime
minister Massimo D'Alema, elected to the country's top job, but
he was rejected by the center right as being too partisan.
Some analysts have suggested that Prodi only put forward
Napolitano as a kind of "stalking horse," intending to revert
to proposing D'Alema if Napolitano does not get broad backing.
On Sunday, Berlusconi's allies put forward four names they
would like to see as candidates, none of them from the DS:
former prime ministers Giuliano Amato and Lamberto Dini, former
European Commissioner Mario Monti and Senate speaker Franco
Whereas outgoing President Ciampi enjoys cross-party
support and was elected in the first round seven years ago, it
took 13 days to elect his predecessor in 1992.
(Additional reporting by Paolo Biondi and Giselda Vagnoni)