For Pigeons, Visible Traits Don’t Necessarily Coincide With Genes
[ Watch the Video ]
Pigeons display spectacular variations in their feathers, feet, beaks and other physical traits, but a new University of Utah study shows that visible traits don’t always coincide with genetics: A bird from one breed may have huge foot feathers, while a closely related breed does not; yet two unrelated pigeon breeds both may have large foot feathers.
“Most people think of pigeons as rats of the sky, but in fact they’re really incredibly diverse,” says Michael Shapiro, an assistant professor of biology and senior author of the study published online Jan. 19 in the journal Current Biology.
More than 350 breeds of pigeons differ in color, color pattern, body size, beak size and shape, structure of the skeleton, posture, vocalizations, feather placement and flight behavior. With help from pigeon breeders worldwide, the researchers studied the genetic relationships and visible traits of 361 pigeons from 70 domestic breeds and two free-living populations, one from Salt Lake City and the other on Scotland’s Isle of Skye.
“What we found through this study is that birds that are only distantly related to each other can have very similar traits, and others that are very closely related to each other can look quite different in terms of their traits,” Shapiro says.
In some cases, birds of a feather don’t stick together — genetically: The old German owl pigeon and English trumpeter both have head feathers known as a head crest, yet the two pigeon breeds aren’t closely related. Another case: English trumpeters have feathers on their feet instead of scales. So do English pouters. Yet they are not closely related.
A few more examples of traits not matching genetics: Pigeon breeds known as the African owl and Budapest short-faced tumbler both have very short beaks, but they are not closely related. The African owl and old German owl pigeon breeds both have short beaks and are closely related, yet the African owl pigeon has a plain head, while the German owl has a head crest. And the English pouter and Brunner pouter are closely related, yet the former has foot feathers and the latter does not.
In other findings from the study:
– Free-living pigeons — including the common city pigeons known as “rats of the sky” — carry the DNA of escaped or lost racing pigeons. Feral rock pigeons living in Salt Lake City are substantially related to a breed known as racing homers. Feral and perhaps wild pigeons from Scotland “are similar to an old domestic breed called the Modena, which used to be a racing pigeon but now is exclusively a show pigeon,” Shapiro says.
– Genetic analysis bolsters the idea that most of these pigeons studied have roots in the Middle East, and some with more recent origins in India.
– Since birds with similar traits may be only distantly related (with no shared ancestors), it means certain traits in pigeons were selected by breeders repeatedly.
“Pigeons are a remarkable example of how selection and heredity work,” Shapiro says. “These breeds are all members of the same species, but look really different. This happened because pigeon fanciers over the ages favored particular traits. This happened in dogs, too. It also happens to animals and other living things in the wild, except the agents of selection and change are environmental factors rather than human preference.”
The Poop on the Coop: Why Care about Pigeons?
Pigeons were domesticated at least 3,000 to 5,000 years ago in the Mediterranean region, and “there is some evidence they were used for ceremonial purposes in Egypt and elsewhere,” as well as a food source, Shapiro says. “It’s not entirely clear when the development of all these interesting traits we see today began.”
He says pigeons “show more variation and diversity [in traits] than any other bird species that we know of. Pigeons are a great example of a species we can use to understand which genes control some of these really interesting traits that we see in many other birds and animals.”
“Charles Darwin was a real pigeon aficionado, and he relied heavily on artificial selection in pigeons to describe how natural selection works in the wild,” says Shapiro. “He spends a lot of time in ‘On the Origin of Species’ discussing pigeons. So pigeons have an important place in the history of evolutionary thought.”
Shapiro notes that “a lot of the variation that we see in different species has to do with an animal’s ability to adapt to its environment. By understanding why some of these traits are so different in pigeons, we can potentially understand which genes are controlling some of these interesting traits in the wild, where these traits can help birds survive and reproduce.”
He adds: “A lot of different animals use exactly the same genes to build similar body structures. By finding genes that control these structures in pigeons, we hope to understand which genes underlie normal diversity in the wild, and possibly even normal and abnormal diversity in humans, including human disease.”
“Pigeons have been used for decades in studies of vision, learning, flight performance, parasites, cardiovascular disease, behavior and navigation,” Shapiro says. “A lot of these topics have direct relevance to human health, so pigeons can help us understand our own biology.”
The discovery that similar looking pigeon breeds aren’t necessarily closely related mirrors similar findings — made in recent years by geneticists at the University of Utah and elsewhere — that human races don’t necessarily reflect underlying genetics.
“On average, people from one population or ‘race’ tend to be more similar genetically to one another than to those of another population,” says Lynn Jorde, chair of the University of Utah’s Department of Human Genetics. “But the race categories we use are quite imperfect and there is a lot of overlap genetically between populations. So there would be many instances in which a black person would be more similar to some white people than to other black people.”
How the Study was Conducted
Shapiro and colleagues used pigeon DNA “microsatellite markers” to group the pigeon breeds according to how similar they are. Genetic material came from pigeon blood samples collected at the Utah Pigeon Club’s 2008 and 2009 shows and the National Pigeon Association’s 2010 show in Salt Lake City. Also, 500 feather samples were collected at a pigeon show in Germany and another 1,000 were mailed to the researchers after they sent e-mails “to every pigeon club we could find on the Internet,” Shapiro says.
Armed with genetic data, the biologists found the pigeon breeds most logically divided into nine groups of closely related breeds: (1) pouters and croppers, (2) three breeds with manes or hoods, (3) and (4) two groups of tumblers and rollers, (5) owl breeds, (6) German toy breeds, (7) homing pigeons and breeds with wattles, (8) fantails, (9) free-living European pigeons and the Modena. Some other breeds are a mixture of several of these groups.
Shapiro, the study’s senior author, coauthored the paper with Sydney Stringham, a doctoral student in biology; Jinchuan Xing, a postdoctoral researcher in Jorde’s human genetics lab; biology postdoctoral researcher Jaclyn Aldenhoven, biology doctoral student Edward Osborne and biology undergraduates Elisabeth Mulroy, David Record and Michael Guernsey.
The study was funded by the Burroughs Wellcome Fund, the National Institutes of Health, the University of Utah and Onorio Catenacci, a Michigan pigeon breeder.
Image 1: These two pigeon breeds — the old Dutch capuchine, left, and komorner tumbler, right — are not closely related, let they both have feathery ornamentation on their heads known as a head crest. These pigeons illustrate the notion that birds of a feather don’t always stick together, at least genetically, according to a new University of Utah study of the pigeon family tree. Photo Credit: Mike Shapiro, University of Utah
Image 2: Long feathers adorn the feet of the Pomeranian pouter pigeon, top, and the ice pigeon, bottom. Even though both breeds share this trait, they are only distantly related, illustrating a new University of Utah study that found visible traits don’t always reflect underlying genetics. Photo Credit: Mike Shapiro, University of Utah
Image 3: The English pouter pigeon breed has feathers on its feet, left, while the Brunner pouter pigeon breed does not, right, yet the two breeds are closely related. University of Utah biologists study pigeons as a model for traits in other birds and animals, and found physical traits don’t always reflect underlying genetics. Photo Credit: Mike Shapiro, University of Utah
On the Net: