Game Theory Can Predict Bizarre Bird Behavior
A team of scientists, led by the University of Exeter, has used game theory to explain the bizarre behavior of a group of ravens. Juvenile birds from a roost in North Wales have been observed adopting the unusual strategy of foraging for food in ‘gangs’. New research, published in the journal PLoS One (on Wednesday 25 February 2009), explains how this curious behavior can be predicted by adapting models more commonly used by economists to analyze financial trends.
This is the first time game theory has been used to successfully predict novel animal behavior in the real world. The researchers believe this analysis could also shed light on the variation in feeding strategies in different populations in other species.
Ravens feed on the carcasses of large animals. Most populations live in temperate forests, where individuals search for carcasses and finds are then defended by a pair of territorial adults. Unpaired younger birds, on the other hand, gather at communal roosts from which they search individually for carcasses on adult territories and recruit each other to overwhelm adult protectionism. However, at one raven roost on Anglesey, things work differently: juveniles forage in gangs. This level of coordination had not been seen before in a raven population.
The researchers built a mathematical model to understand how this behavior evolved and why it might occur in some roosts and not others. The model designed for this study was based on techniques used in other game theory models, which identify the most profitable behaviors of individuals in different situations to predict what would be favored by evolution.
The study revealed two strategies as being most profitable for ravens to find food. One is for birds to search independently for food and recruit each other. The other is for the birds to forage in gangs.
The findings showed that gang foraging should occur when searching for food individually is no more efficient than foraging in groups. This is likely to be the case if the roost covers landscape that can be thoroughly explored by a gang over the course of a day. The deforested Welsh countryside offers just such conditions.
The study also identifies the availability of food as a key factor. The roost in Anglesey is situated in an agricultural area, which means that the carcasses of farm animals are often available so food is more plentiful than in wild locations. When food is abundant, the opportunity for social advancement becomes more important. These ravens seem to be using foraging behavior, not only to find food, but also to gain social status, which could help in other aspects of their lives, including finding a mate.
Lead author Dr Sasha Dall of the University of Exeter said: “This is a rare example of how game theory has been used to predict behavior in animals in the real world. Our study shows the potential for game theory to help biologists understand how different social structures and behaviors evolve in different environments and in response to human activities.”
This study, entitled Rich pickings near large communal roosts favor ‘gang’ foraging by juvenile common ravens, Corvus corax, was carried out by a team from the University of Exeter’s Cornwall Campus and the Institute of Biology, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway.
On the Net: