January 4, 2010
Head-To-Head Studies Identify Best Treatment Regimen For Hep C
Peginterferon alpha-2a may yield higher response rate than peginterferon alpha-2b
In patients with chronic hepatitis C, treatment with peginterferon alpha-2a (PegIFNÃ±2a) plus ribavirin (RBV) better suppresses the virus to undetectable levels in the blood than treatment with peginterferon alpha-2b (PegIFNÃ±2b) plus RBV, according to two new head-to-head studies in Gastroenterology, the official journal of the American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) Institute.
While previous trials have demonstrated that both pegylated interferons are effective and safe when administered with RBV, only two randomized clinical studies have compared the efficacy of the peginterferon formulations, neither of which was sufficiently powered to detect a statistically significant difference in SVR rates.
"Head-to-head trials comparing the efficacy and safety of PegIFNÃ±2a or PegIFNÃ±2b in combination with RBV in the treatment of patients with chronic hepatitis C are needed," said Massimo Colombo, MD, of the University of Milan and author of one of the head-to-head studies published in Gastroenterology. "There is insufficient evidence to support conclusions that one therapeutic regimen is superior to the other one."
In the first study, previously untreated patients with chronic hepatitis C were randomly assigned after stratification for HCV genotype to either RBV combined with PegIFNÃ±2a or PegIFNÃ±2b for 24 or 48 weeks, according to virus genotype. Researchers found that overall, the SVR rate was significantly higher in PegIFNÃ±2a than in PegIFNÃ±2b (66 percent versus 54 percent).
"Whether our strategy of RBV dosing, which is at variance with the standard of care for PegIFNÃ±2a treatment, is indeed cost-effective, needs to be prospectively assessed through a pharmaco-economy study," added Dr. Colombo.
Similar results were reported in a second study published in Gastroenterology. In this single-center, randomized, head-to-head study, 320 consecutive, treatment-naÃÂ¯ve, HCV-RNA-positive patients with chronic hepatitis were randomly assigned to groups given once-weekly subcutaneous PegIFNÃ±2a or PegIFNÃ±2b plus RBV 1,000 mg/day or 1,200 mg/day for 48 weeks or 24 weeks. More patients in the PegIFNÃ±2a group than the PegIFNÃ±2b group achieved SVR (68.8 percent versus 54.4 percent).
In fact, study authors found that in patients with chronic HCV infection, treatment with PegIFNÃ±2a plus RBV produced a significantly higher SVR rate than treatment with PegIFNÃ±2b plus RBV; the safety profile of the two regimens were similar.
"The fact that both of these studies yielded similar and significant results confirms the potential advantages of PegIFNÃ±2a plus RBV versus PegIFNÃ±2b plus RBV," said Antonio Ascione, MD, of Fatebenefratelli Hospital in Naples and lead author of this study. "These advantages may translate to the development of promising new direct anti-viral drugs against HCV."
On the Net: