September 20, 2010
No Rest For The Narcissist
Narcissists spend their resting time deep in thought, a new imaging study shows, though such reflection likely revolves entirely around the thinker.
USC neuroscientists found a correlation between high scores on a measure of narcissism - the Machiavellian Egocentricity subscale - and activity during rest in the posteromedial cortex, a brain region that previous studies have associated with thoughts about the self.The finding, published online by PLoS ONE, does more than bolster a stereotype. Since narcissism is one component of the psychopathic mind, differences between the brain patterns of normals and narcissists may help psychiatrists to understand and treat dangerous individuals.
"Perhaps the fact that psychopathy [like personality traits in general] tends to be stable across life might be due to neural mechanisms," said Tong Sheng, the study's lead author.
The study also found a correlation between poor decision-making and brain activity during rest in the medial prefrontal cortex. Impulsive action without regard for consequences is another aspect of psychopathic behavior.
The researchers, led by senior author Lisa Aziz-Zadeh, analyzed brain regions active during rest because they are believed to support a baseline state of thought that includes reflection about the self.
Other studies have linked the posteromedial cortex and medial prefrontal cortex to self-reflective thought.
Activity in the resting state falls off when a person starts a task or reacts to a stimulus, supporting the hypothesis that resting state activity has to do with unstructured recall and reflection.
The study involved 19 healthy volunteers who had their brains scanned by functional magnetic resonance imaging at rest and while performing a task.
Outside the scanner, the subjects took psychological tests to measure narcissism and decision-making.
The researchers wanted to answer a simple question, Aziz-Zadeh said: "If these regions are actually important for self-processing, are people who are more narcissistic going to activate these regions even more?"
The answer appears to be yes.
"The higher you score on the narcissistic scale, the greater activity you have in this region [the posteromedial cortex] during rest," Aziz-Zadeh said.
Her team also found a correlation between poor scores on the decision-making test and activity in the medial prefrontal cortex.
The researchers measured the intensity of activity in the resting state by comparing it to activity in the same regions during performance of a task.
Subjects who scored high in narcissism showed a greater drop in activity in the posteromedial cortex when asked to perform a task.
More impulsive subjects showed a similar drop in the medial prefrontal cortex. This makes sense, Aziz-Zadeh explained, since that region seems to be involved in decisions. Subjects who struggle to control their impulses would be expected to show neural deficits in decision-making.
The study is the first to show a correlation between narcissism and activity in the posteromedial cortex, Aziz-Zadeh said.
"More generally, these findings suggest a link between [resting state] activity and personality traits," she concluded.
Aziz-Zadeh is an assistant professor in the USC Brain and Creativity Institute, part of USC College, with a joint appointment in the Division of Occupational Sciences and Occupational Therapy at the Herman Ostrow School of Dentistry of USC.
Her co-authors were corresponding author Sheng, a doctoral student in neuroscience at USC, and second author Anahita Gheytanchi, a postdoctoral researcher at the Pacific Graduate School of Psychology in Palo Alto, Calif.
The study was funded by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health & Human Development, a USC James H. Zumberge Individual Award, the USC Brain and Creativity Institute and the USC Dornsife Cognitive Neuroimaging Center.
On the Net: