Judge Claims Orcas Aren't Endangered Species
Posted on: Thursday, 18 December 2003, 06:00 CST
By PEGGY ANDERSEN
SEATTLE (AP) -- A federal judge Wednesday ordered the government to rethink its finding that Washington state's struggling orca population is not significant and does not warrant protection under the Endangered Species Act.
The National Marine Fisheries Service last year listed killer whales in Puget Sound as depleted but not endangered, a move that protected individual orcas but not their habitat.
Although the agency said the region's inland orcas "face a relatively high risk of extinction," it ruled that they were not a "significant population segment" and that orcas along the coast would fill the gap if they disappeared.
U.S. District Judge Robert Lasnik rejected that finding, calling it speculative and unsupported. He also said the fisheries service did not use the best available science when it based its decision on the health of the global orca population rather than the local population.
"The judge has given the Puget Sound killer whales the best Christmas gift they could have been afforded," said Fred Felleman of Orca Conservancy, one of six plaintiffs represented by the Center for Biological Diversity and Earthjustice.
Fisheries service spokesman Brian Gorman said officials had not decided whether to appeal the ruling, which gives the agency a year to reconsider it decision.
The fisheries service also must consider whether the orcas are endangered over a significant part of their range, Lasnik ruled - a factor that was not considered last year.
The Puget Sound orca population numbers 84, down from an unknown high that the plaintiffs suggested could have topped 200 at one time.
The whales have been struggling with pollution, human encroachment and dwindling salmon runs.
-----
On the Net:
Center for Biological Diversity
National Marine Fisheries Service
More science, space, and technology from RedNova
Copyright © 2003 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. The information contained in the AP News report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press.
Related Articles
- Pew Urges National Marine Fisheries Service to Protect Bluefin Tuna, Ban Long-line Fishing in the Gulf of Mexico
- Statement by Glen Libby, President of the Midcoast (Maine) Fishermen's Association, on the Final Interim Rule for Groundfish for the 2009 Fishing Year Released by the National Marine Fisheries Service
- Statement from Lee Crockett, Director, Federal Fisheries Policy, Pew Environment Group, on the Bush Administration Finalizing the National Marine Fisheries Service's Annual Catch Limit Rule
- Expand Networks Terminal Services Optimization Solution Enables BurrellesLuce to Significantly Improve Network Performance
- Caribbean Monk Seal Declared Extinct By National Marine Fisheries Service
- CORRECTING and REPLACING Key ASIC and Silterra Partner to Deliver Design-to-Manufacture Services Targeted for Mobile and Consumer Electronics Markets
- Earthjustice Opposes Judge Alito's Nomination to Supreme Court; 1st Environmental Opposition to Supreme Court Nominee Since Bork in 1987
- Groups Sue National Marine Fisheries Service to Protect Right Whales From Deadly Ship Strikes; Agency Stalls As Right Whale Numbers Dwindle
- GigaMedia and Hutchison Launch Network Service Targeting Growing Telecom Demands in Taiwan, Hong Kong and China
- At&T to Change Marketing Plan ; Company Plans to Curb; Traditional Long-Distance Service, Target Businesses
 |
 |
User Comments (0)
RSS Feeds