• E-mail
• Print
• Comment
• Font Size
• Digg
• del.icio.us
• Discuss article

Cutting 10G costs with copper

Posted on: Saturday, 4 October 2003, 06:00 CDT

The idea of lower costs for short-distance applications is driving two IEEE efforts to standardize 10G Ethernet over copper.

When it comes to 10G Ethernet, what's good for fiber is good for copper. Or so think two IEEE working groups readying versions of the 802.3ae standard for carrying this ultra-fast Ethernet over copper.

Proponents say 10G Ethernet over copper would be ideal for short- distance interconnections - stacking in wiring closets, switch-to- switch or server cluster links in a data center, and potentially connections to power user desktops, for example. And it would provide a less-expensive alternative to fiber for super-fast enterprise switching, proponents say.

The 10G Ethernet-over-copper standards would be complementary, with both suitable for short-distance applications but one perhaps better for high-speed connections within devices such as servers, says Dan Dove, task force chairman and principal engineer for LAN physical layer technology at HP's ProCurve Networking Business.

The IEEE's 10Base CX4 task force proposes a method for carrying 10G Ethernet over four pairs of twin-axial cabling. The distance limitation is 50 feet. In the meantime, the other IEEE group is looking at 10G Ethernet over twisted-pair wiring. This 10GBase-T method would be capable of supporting connections up to 300 feet.

Products by 2005

The CX4 group says it hopes to gain formal 802.3 committee approval for its standard early next year, and Dove says he expects to see products based on the standard shortly after that. Standardization of the 10GBase-T method would trail by at least a year.

"CX4 will help bring down costs for short data connections. Cable is more expensive than fiber, but for short-reach connections the total cost [of copper] will be lower" says Brad Booth, chairman of the 10GBase-T study group and an architect in the Intel Communications Group. "When Base-T shows up, we expect it will absorb some of the CX4 market."

The 10GBase-T study group is working on a project approval request (PAR), which must show that the technology has broad market potential, is distinct from and compatible with existing standards, and is technically and economically feasible. The study group hopes to get the PAR completed by November. If the 802.3 committee then approves the PAR, a task force can begin work on a standard. Products based on such a standard wouldn't materialize until mid to late 2005, Booth says.

The IEEE folks say transitioning from the earlier CX4 standard to the Base-T version shouldn't be difficult because they both likely would use the XAUI interface specification. Chip, switch and cable vendors that have pledged support for at least one of the standards efforts include 3Com, Avaya, Broadcom, Cisco, Extreme Networks, Force 10 Networks, Foundry Networks, HP, Intel, Marvell and Solarflare.

Some analysts and users also see opportunities for 10G Ethernet over copper."In many environments where you have high-density switches connected to servers, or switches aggregated together that are not too far apart, copper makes a lot of sense," says Sean Lavey networking analyst at IDC.

Mike Bennett, senior network engineer at the U.S. Department of Energy, says copper-based 10G Ethernet networks could cost 50% less than fiber networks.

Mike Bennett, senior network engineer at the U.S. Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in Berkeley, Calif., says 10G Ethernet over copper could be used to link switches and routers in the lab's data centers "or anyplace where we have high- performance computing in clusters." But he doesn't foresee much demand for 10G to the desktop, at least yet.

Bennett says the main driver to using copper 10G Ethernet will be lower overall costs, compared with fiber connections. Lower-priced switches and other gear using copper will be particularly compelling at a time when IT budgets remain tight, he adds.

Lower price would be the only driver for 10G Ethernet over copper, says Carlos Leon, computer operations manager at Contractors Register, a publisher of construction directories in Jefferson Valley, N.Y. His company recently installed a 1G bit/sec Ethernet switch for transferring large volumes of data between servers, and is using copper and fiber for gigabit networking. Needing 10G Ethernet is "hard to fathom" at this point, Leon says.

"We'll wait until the dust settles on standards," Leon says. "In the future, I'm sure there will be demand for greater throughput." However, he says, "Price would be the only reason we'd look at [10G Ethernet over copper]."

A rise in demand for Gigabit Ethernet connections to the desktop also will help fuel demand for less-expensive, copper-based versions. "We're seeing more traction for gigabit to the desktop, and copper in general is a media that enables lower price points," says Seamus Crehan, senior analyst at Dell'Oro Group."That will make it attractive for desktop connections."

Copper costs less

Some estimates put 10G Ethernet over copper at half the cost of a fiber alternative.

Network analysts and vendors expect copper versions of 10G Ethernet to provide less-expensive alternatives to fiber. And that, of course, is good news for network managers.

"The prices for optical versions of 10Gig are coming down, but they're still high at about $15,000 per port," says Mike Bennett, senior network engineer at the U.S. Departement of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in Berkeley, Calif. "In a data center, that adds up pretty quickly."

Bennett, who's following both standards efforts, says it's still unclear how much copper will affect pricing when the standards are completed. He says copper-based 10G Ethernet networks could be 50% less expensive than optical networks.

"There are substantial cost implications," of copper 10G Ethernet, says Dan Dove, chairman of the IEEE 10GBase-CX4 task force and principal engineer for LAN physical layer technology at HP's ProCurve Networking Business.

He says the group, one of two working on a standard, is aiming tor the IEEE's traditional goal of increasing speed by a factor of 10 while keeping prices at no more than two to three times the cost of existing technology - in this case, that being 1G over copper, which costs approximately $200 per port.

Dove says the price of copper 100 networks likely will be two to three times less than that of comparable fiber networks. The presence of a copper alternative also will help drive competitive price decreases for fiber-based 10G Ethernet equipment. "Providing a copper link will accelerate the growth of the 10Gig market and will bring down the cost of optical solutions," Dove says.

Sean Lavey, network analyst at IDC, agrees copper will provide significant savings compared with fiber for short-distance applications. "It will make a lot of sense if you can move some traffic to copper."

-Bob Violino

Violino is a freelance writer covering business and technology. He can be reached at rviolino@optonline.net.

Copyright Network World Inc. Sep 22, 2003

More News in this Category